Manchester residents shape a proposed AI advice service

Manchester residents proposed safeguards for a public-facing Caddy service. Wider access to understandable advice remains intended; the panel’s design recommendations are reported.

AI system

System

Proposed public-facing Caddy AI advice service

Model

Not assessed

Release

Not assessed

Application developer

Citizens Advice Stockport, Oldham, Rochdale and Trafford

Role

Not assessed

Configuration

Not assessed

Inputs and outputs

Not assessed

Autonomy

Not assessed

Workflow

Residents supplied design recommendations for a proposed AI advice service. Improvements from the resulting service remain unverified.

Human oversight

Not assessed

Relation to AI

Caddy would support public-facing advice. The panel generated the design recommendations; the intended AI contribution to advice outcomes has not been evaluated.

AI contribution

Not assessed

Benefits

Outcome identifiers

Not assessed

Benefit

Manchester residents proposed safeguards for a public-facing Caddy service. Wider access to understandable advice remains intended; the panel’s design recommendations are reported.

Category

Improved Accessibility

Status

Intended benefit

Beneficiary groups

People. Organizations.

Beneficiaries

Not assessed

Reach

Not assessed

Distribution and access

Not assessed

Duration

Not assessed

Expected?

Yes

Costs and harms

Not assessed

Measurement

Studies

Not assessed

Study design

Not assessed

Measurement

Not assessed

Setting and sample

Not assessed

Measures

Not assessed

Comparison

Not assessed

Results

Not assessed

Additional value from AI

Not assessed

Limitations

Not assessed

Denominators

Not assessed

Materials for replication

Not assessed

Money

Kind of value

Not assessed

Amount

Not assessed

Currency and prices

Not assessed

Period and unit

Not assessed

Realization

Not assessed

Recipients and payers

Not assessed

Gross or net

Not assessed

Included costs

Not assessed

Comparison

Not assessed

Method

Not assessed

Return and payback

Not assessed

People and places

Participants

Developer: Citizens Advice Stockport, Oldham, Rochdale and Trafford. Operator: Citizens Advice Stockport, Oldham, Rochdale and Trafford (proposed public-facing service).

Jurisdictions

Benefit: Manchester, United Kingdom.

Ownership and control

Not assessed

Dependencies

Not assessed

Cross-border connections

Not assessed

Geopolitical implications

Not assessed

Follow-up

Conditions for replication

Implementation and evaluation would be needed to determine whether the proposed service improves access. Conditions sufficient for a beneficial outcome remain unknown.

Replication attempts

Not assessed

Later findings

Not assessed

Availability

Not assessed

Institutional decision

Not assessed

Grounds

Not assessed

Action and result

Not assessed

Success criterion

Not assessed

Evidence

Source numbers

AIBD-0575-source-0001–0003

Citations

Numbered references below. [1] [2] [3]

Language

Not assessed

Source relationships

Operator [1] [2] [3]

Original evidence

The sources are listed below. [1] [2] [3]

Access and versions

Not assessed

Supported findings

Not assessed

Evidence strength

Not assessed

Missing evidence

Not assessed

Grades

Assessed benefits

People. Organizations.

Depth

Not assessed

Reasons

People: Advice recipients are intended beneficiaries. The proposed design has no established client outcome. Organizations: Citizens Advice received specific design input. Its contribution to service capability and performance remains unassessed.

Observed or intended

Intended benefit

Rubric

Not assessed

Assessor and date

Not assessed

Alternative assessments

Not assessed

Fill

The deployer's account

Entry details

Kind

Not assessed

Field

Public advice and community participation.

Purpose

Extend access to understandable advice through a proposed public-facing AI service with human escalation and user choice.

Dates

Source published: 2 September 2026. Updated: 24 October 2026.

Stage

Not assessed

Version

SHA-256: 777f01cda89e…

References

Other identifiers

LGA AI case-study bank. LGA-015.

Category mappings

Not assessed

Brief

Not assessed

Revisions

2 revisions. Latest: 24 October 2026.

Sources

  1. Other Deployer

    Stuart Pearson, Citizens Advice SORT, LinkedIn, September 2, 2026. First-person account of proposed service design and panel feedback.

    deployer

  2. Other Deployer

    Stuart Pearson interview in the Open University course Use cases for Generative AI, section People’s Panel for Artificial Intelligence. Describes Citizens Advice SORT’s July 2024 presentation to the council-funded panel. Publication date unspecified.

    deployer

  3. Report Deployer

    Manchester City Council account published by the Local Government Association, January 28, 2025. Describes the council-funded People’s Panel and its educational survey results. The proposed Caddy service was not evaluated.

    deployer