{ "schema_version": "1.0", "version": "1.0.0", "title": "AIBD mandatory field coverage specification", "availability_states": { "value_present": "A value is recorded with source, derivation, or curatorial provenance. This status alone does not certify truth or causality.", "not_reported": "The identified sources were checked for this question and do not report the answer. Record the source scope and review date.", "unresolved": "Available reviewed evidence does not settle the answer. Preserve the competing possibilities and their evidence.", "not_assessed": "The question remains unreviewed. It remains a gap and cannot satisfy completed curation.", "not_applicable": "The question has no meaningful referent for the case or related object. Record the scope reason. Source silence is insufficient.", "withheld": "A value is known internally but is restricted in the public view. Preserve authorized internal access and disclosure rules.", "source_unavailable": "A relevant identified source could not be inspected. Record the source, limitation, access-attempt date, and follow-up status." }, "conditional_families": { "strategic assessments": 1, "evaluations": 11, "monetary observations": 11, "institutional decisions": 4 }, "fields": [ { "key": "id", "label": "Stable AIBD identifier", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Preserve the existing identifier and URL through corrections.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "id", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "case_kind", "label": "Kind of case", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Individual experience, deployment, program/activity, evaluation/study, or another defined unit. Link components of the same project.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "case_links[]", "label": "Related cases and counting relationship", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Link the same deployment, evaluation, replication, duplicate, or incident. Do not count additional articles as additional benefits.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "registry_ids; source_collection; source_entry", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "title", "label": "Title", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Name the activity and claimed or observed benefit plainly.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "title; headline", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "summary", "label": "Short account", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "State what happened, for whom, and the main qualification.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "summary; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "sector", "label": "Sector and application domain", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Support sector and task filtering without forcing one exclusive category.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "domain; segment", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "purpose", "label": "Intended purpose", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Distinguish the deployment's purpose from a benefit that emerged unexpectedly.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "purpose", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "record_dates", "label": "Dates and precision", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Separate occurrence start/end, first publication, database discovery, added date, and last checked date. Allow unknown dates and day/month/year precision.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "date_observed; date_basis; date_precision; revisions", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "deployment_stage", "label": "Stage of use", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Proposed, simulated, laboratory test, pilot, routine use, scaling, retired, or unknown. This is separate from benefit evidence.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "version", "label": "Record version", "group": "Case identity and dates", "definition": "Identify the exact published version that a user cited.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "revisions; new explicit version", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].product_name", "label": "AI product or system", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Identify the application actually used, including an in-house system. A vendor name alone is insufficient.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "system", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].model_name", "label": "Underlying model", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Record the model behind the application when known. Allow several components with different roles.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "system; model_version", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].model_version", "label": "Exact model version", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Preserve the AI model version, checkpoint, release, or snapshot that was used in this case. Record hardware models under actual configuration and paper revisions under access and source version. A product name, device generation, publication revision, or current repository commit does not establish the deployed AI model version.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "model_version", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].provider", "label": "Model or system provider", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Distinguish the model provider from the application developer and organization operating it.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "developer", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].component_role", "label": "Role in the system", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Identify generation, retrieval, classification, planning, verification, perception, or another component function.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].deployment_configuration", "label": "Actual configuration", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Record the hardware model and application or interface version separately from the AI model version. Include wrappers, retrieval, fine-tuning, tools, inference budget, agent coordination, and weight or API access when they materially affect the result. Distinguish a published reproducibility configuration from a verified deployment snapshot.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "replication.produced_by; new structure", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].inputs_outputs", "label": "Inputs and outputs", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Describe data types, languages, provenance, and outputs relevant to the task, subject to access restrictions.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "purpose; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "systems[].autonomy_permissions", "label": "Autonomy and permissions", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Record what the AI could decide or execute, tool permissions, and escalation or approval boundaries.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "workflow", "label": "Human and organizational workflow", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Explain who used the AI, what they did before and after it, and which decisions remained human.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "account; replication.produced_by", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "human_oversight", "label": "Human review and safeguards", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Review steps, responsible roles, override options, training, and controls in the actual deployment.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "replication.must_hold", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "ai_relationship", "label": "How the benefit relates to AI", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Direct AI use, AI-related education, AI-related convening, institutional activity, another identified relationship, or unresolved. Record the actual route to benefit.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ai_role; category", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "ai_contribution", "label": "AI contribution and alternative explanation", "group": "AI system and use", "definition": "Distinguish AI's contribution from human work, ordinary digitization, or other simultaneous changes. The contribution may be unassessed.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ai_role", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "actors[]", "label": "Actors and roles", "group": "Organizations and geography", "definition": "Identify developer, model provider, deployer, operator, evaluator, funder, and beneficiaries where relevant. A single actor can hold several roles.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "developer; deployer", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "places[]", "label": "Places with defined roles", "group": "Organizations and geography", "definition": "Separate development, compute/hosting, physical site, deployment, beneficiary location, actor headquarters, and applicable jurisdiction. Include place resolution and source.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "location; developer_country; deployer_country", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "actors[].ownership_control", "label": "Ownership or effective control", "group": "Organizations and geography", "definition": "Record ownership or control only where documented and relevant. Headquarters does not establish nationality, state control, or allegiance.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "infrastructure_dependencies[]", "label": "Physical and digital dependencies", "group": "Organizations and geography", "definition": "Link hosting/compute, chips, connectivity, energy, water, suppliers, data access, and locations when material to use or replication.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "replication.must_hold", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "cross_border_flows[]", "label": "Cross-border relationships", "group": "Organizations and geography", "definition": "Record sourced flows of data, compute, services, funding, or value, with origin, destination, and relationship type.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "strategic_assessments[]", "label": "Geopolitical interpretation", "group": "Organizations and geography", "definition": "Specify the country or institution whose interests are being assessed, security/economic domain, assessed capability change, rationale, confidence, sources, and date.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "strategic assessments", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "outcomes[].id", "label": "Outcome identifier", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Give each distinct stakeholder-specific outcome a stable identifier within the case.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].claim", "label": "Benefit statement", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "State the particular claimed or observed change. Retain multiple outcomes without duplicating the deployment count.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "benefit_type; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].benefit_type", "label": "Benefit category", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Use a versioned benefit category and preserve source wording where it differs.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "benefit_type; taxonomy_note", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].status", "label": "Outcome status", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Intended, observed, mixed, not demonstrated, reversed, or unclear. Distinguish status from confidence and deployment stage.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "benefit_status; later.status", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].stakeholder_group", "label": "Beneficiary class", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Personal, organizational, or societal. Apply the existing shape grammar to the relevant outcome.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ratings.group", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].beneficiaries", "label": "Specific beneficiaries", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Describe the people or organizations that benefit, rather than stopping at an abstract class.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ratings.reason; value.who", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].beneficiary_count", "label": "Beneficiary count and reach", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Count actually benefiting, merely exposed, eligible, and intended populations separately. Preserve unit, period, estimation basis, and overlap limits.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "metric; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].distribution", "label": "Distribution and access", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Record relevant differences by subgroup, geography, income, language, disability, or access conditions when evidence supports them.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].duration", "label": "Duration and persistence", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Distinguish a one-time result from recurring or sustained benefit and state the observation horizon.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "later; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].unexpected", "label": "Expected or unexpected", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Expected, unexpected, partly unexpected, or unknown. Do not infer intention from the presence of a positive outcome.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "unexpected; purpose", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "outcomes[].tradeoffs", "label": "Costs, burdens, and harms to stakeholders", "group": "Benefits and beneficiaries", "definition": "Record costs or harms to the same beneficiaries and to other parties, with timing and evidence. Link relevant incident records where available.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "paired_incident; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "evaluations[].id", "label": "Evaluation identifier", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Identify an evaluation independently of its reports and the outcomes that it measures.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].design", "label": "Evaluation design", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Randomized, quasi-experimental, controlled observational, before/after, qualitative evaluation, case study, simulation, testimonial, forecast, or other. Record the actual design.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "evidence.kind; new structure", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].measurement_method", "label": "Measurement method", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Instrument, administrative data, observation, interview, survey, model estimate, or another method. Preserve qualitative findings without forcing a number.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "evidence; account; new structure", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].setting_sample", "label": "Setting and sample", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Population, eligibility, sample size, sites, recruitment, allocation, and study period where reported.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "replication; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].metric", "label": "Measured outcome", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Metric name, exact operational definition, value, unit, numerator, denominator, and period. Retain source wording and distinguish proxy from ultimate outcome.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "metric", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].comparator", "label": "Comparator and baseline", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "No AI, prior workflow, human-only work, another AI system, another intervention, or no comparator. Record the exact baseline and comparison period.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "comparator", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].effect", "label": "Difference from the comparator", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Absolute and relative effects with their units, uncertainty interval, calculation, and source. Do not combine incompatible measures.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "comparator.before; comparator.after", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].ai_uplift", "label": "Increment attributable to AI", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Assess changes in cost, time, quality, scale, access, or capability relative to the alternative. Separate estimated contribution from total observed improvement.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "ai_role; comparator", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].uncertainty_limitations", "label": "Uncertainty and limitations", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Record sampling uncertainty, confounding, missing observations, selection, failed comparisons, and bounds on causal interpretation.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "account; brief_notes", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].exposure", "label": "Exposure denominator", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Population at risk or eligible to benefit, uses, agent-hours, task-hours, transactions, distance, or another matched denominator, with source and period.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "evaluations[].reproduction_materials", "label": "Reproduction materials", "group": "Measurement and comparison", "definition": "Protocols, logs, prompts, action traces, code, data, and evaluation artifacts with model/configuration and permitted use.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "evidence; replication", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "evaluations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].measure_type", "label": "Kind of monetary value", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Cash saving, labor capacity freed, revenue, profit, recovered money, avoided loss, recipient transfer, willingness to pay, or another stated valuation. Preserve these distinctions.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.what", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].amount", "label": "Amount", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Store the numerical figure with its original quoted amount. Distinguish an outcome level from an incremental gain. Zero differs from unknown.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.amount", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].currency_price_basis", "label": "Currency and price basis", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Original currency, price year when relevant, nominal/real basis, and any documented conversion rate/date. Retain the original amount after conversion.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.amount; new structure", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].period_unit", "label": "Period and unit", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "One-time or recurring, period covered, per-user/per-task/per-organization/total basis, and population or volume to which the estimate applies.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.what", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].realization", "label": "Realization and estimation status", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Observed cash flow, measured resource saving, estimated monetary value, forecast, or target. A time saving is not automatically a cash saving.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.estimate", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].recipient_payer", "label": "Who benefits and who pays", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Identify the recipient of value and each cost bearer. Separate organizational savings from worker or societal effects.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.who", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].gross_net", "label": "Gross or net", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Gross, net, or unspecified. State which cost categories the estimate includes or excludes.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].costs[]", "label": "Cost components", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Purchase, integration, training, infrastructure, operation, maintenance, human review, compliance, transition, and other documented costs, with time basis.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].counterfactual", "label": "Economic comparator", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Specify the alternative against which costs or gains are measured. Preserve differences in quality, volume, and time horizon.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "comparator", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].valuation_method", "label": "Calculation and assumptions", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Show the source's method, rates, unit conversions, discount rate if applicable, uncertainty, and sensitivity. Label any AIBD calculation explicitly.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "value.quote; value.url", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "economics[].return_payback", "label": "Return or payback", "group": "Monetary value and costs", "definition": "Retain a source-reported ROI or payback period, or a transparent calculation with matched inputs. State numerator, denominator, and horizon.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "monetary observations", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "sources[].id", "label": "Source identifier", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Identify each report or evidence artifact separately from the case.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "evidence", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "sources[].citation_locator", "label": "Citation and exact locator", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Title, author/publisher, URL or persistent identifier, publication date, page/paragraph/table, and a short supporting excerpt when permitted.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "evidence.citation; title; url; date; quote", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "sources[].language", "label": "Source language and translation", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Original language, translation status/method, and original wording needed to verify a consequential claim.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "sources[].relationship", "label": "Source relationship and interests", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Maker, deployer, beneficiary, evaluator, independent reporter, funder, other, or unclear relationship. Unknown does not default to independent. Record disclosed funding/conflicts separately from research design.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "evidence.written_by", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "sources[].upstream_sources", "label": "Shared evidence lineage", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Identify reports that repeat the same press release, study, witness, or dataset. Several articles may constitute one evidentiary origin.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "sources[].access_version", "label": "Access and source version", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Access date, source version, archive/persistent link when permitted, corrections or retractions, and availability limits.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "evidence; revisions", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "claims[].proposition", "label": "Precisely supported claim", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Tie evidence to the exact factual assertion, outcome, actor attribution, or AI-contribution claim. Publicly identify source statements, analyst inferences, and generated summaries.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "evidence.quote; ai_role; account", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "claims[].evidence_links", "label": "Supporting and contradicting evidence", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Link the exact passage and distinguish support, contradiction, and contextual evidence.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "evidence; new claim-level linkage", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "claims[].evidence_strength", "label": "Evidence assessment", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Assess occurrence, outcome, AI contribution, and actor attribution separately where relevant, with reasons and an explicit unassessed state.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "computed confidence; ai_role", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "claims[].missingness", "label": "Missing information", "group": "Sources and claim evidence", "definition": "Distinguish not reported, unknown after review, not assessed, not applicable, withheld, and disputed. Do not substitute zero or false.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "unrated_because; new general form", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].target", "label": "Assessment target", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Identify the exact benefit and beneficiary to which the rating applies.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ratings.group", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].depth", "label": "Depth of benefit", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Keep the current depth scale and color mapping. Money, beneficiary count, confidence, and strategic significance remain separate dimensions.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ratings.depth", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].rationale", "label": "Rating rationale", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Explain why the observed or intended benefit fits the stated depth for that stakeholder.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "ratings.reason", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].status_basis", "label": "Observed or intended basis", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "State whether the depth describes a realized, intended, projected, or unclear outcome. Assess support separately: a claim can concern a realized result. Keep unrealized benefits eligible.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "benefit_status; new explicit link", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].rubric_version", "label": "Rubric and taxonomy version", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Identify the definitions and rules under which the assessment was made.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "taxonomy_note; new versions", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].assessor_date", "label": "Assessor and assessment date", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Store who assessed the claim and when. Use a public role or pseudonym where disclosure requires it.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "revisions.editor; revisions.date", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].alternatives", "label": "Disagreement and alternatives", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Preserve materially different ratings, rationales, and unresolved questions rather than averaging them away.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "brief_notes; new structure", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "assessments[].display_confidence", "label": "Confidence shown by fill", "group": "Ratings and interpretations", "definition": "Support for the beneficial outcome and its stated relationship to AI. Certainty that someone made a claim or that a benefit failed is separate. Retain unassessed. Do not infer confidence from publisher prestige alone.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "confidence property; evidence_word", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "replication.conditions", "label": "Conditions needed to repeat the benefit", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Skills, data, language, infrastructure, workflows, controls, and contextual prerequisites that evidence identifies.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "replication.produced_by; replication.must_hold", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "replication.attempts[]", "label": "Attempts to reproduce the result", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Setting, population, model/version, protocol differences, observed result, source, and independent/same-team relationship. Include failed attempts.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "replication.echoes", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "follow_up[]", "label": "Subsequent outcomes", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Track persisted, scaled, mixed, reversed, withdrawn, or unknown outcomes and relevant changes in model or context.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "later", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "availability", "label": "Access and availability", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Whether and how the system/activity can be accessed, procurement or license conditions, cost, geographic/language availability, and as-of date.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "decisions[].institution_task", "label": "Institution and decision", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Identify who was deciding whether to adopt, fund, scale, regulate, or stop a use, and the task that evidence served.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "institutional decisions", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "decisions[].grounds", "label": "Decision grounds and alternatives", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Relevant mandate, jurisdiction, threshold, evidence considered, alternatives, reasons to act or not act, and constraints.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "institutional decisions", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "decisions[].action_outcome", "label": "Action and observed consequence", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Record what was done, who owned it, when, and what later evidence showed. Distinguish intended response from tested effectiveness.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "later; new decision linkage", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "institutional decisions", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "decisions[].success_criterion", "label": "What would show success", "group": "Replication, follow-up, and decisions", "definition": "Preserve the measurable question that would establish whether the adoption or intervention worked, with unanswered follow-up questions.", "previous_scope": "Specialist", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "conditional_family": "institutional decisions", "resolution_rule": "Resolve the family applicability and evidence status for every case. If a genuine related record exists, resolve every applicable child definition. An explicitly reviewed family absence covers child definitions without creating empty records." }, { "key": "external_references[]", "label": "Other databases and identifiers", "group": "Interoperability and publication", "definition": "Link original collection entries, risk/incident records, studies, registries, and standards without implying that they are equivalent records.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "registry_ids; source_collection; source_entry; paired_incident", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "taxonomy_crosswalks[]", "label": "Versioned category mappings", "group": "Interoperability and publication", "definition": "Record exact, broader, narrower, partial, or no-match mappings with rationale and versions. Retain disagreement.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "taxonomy_note; new structure", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "brief", "label": "Citable case brief", "group": "Interoperability and publication", "definition": "Present the main result, comparison, beneficiary, material limitations, and source links. Preserve qualifications in export.", "previous_scope": "Detail", "current_mapping": "brief; brief_notes", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "revision_history[]", "label": "Field-level changes", "group": "Interoperability and publication", "definition": "Changed field, old/new values or recoverable versions, date, source, editor, and correction reason.", "previous_scope": "Core", "current_mapping": "revisions", "level": "case-associated", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "collections[].scope", "label": "Collection scope", "group": "Collection and editorial operations", "definition": "Define countries, languages, sectors, dates, source classes, and inclusion rules actually searched.", "previous_scope": "Collection", "current_mapping": "source_collection; new collection object", "level": "collection", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "collections[].ascertainment", "label": "How candidates were found", "group": "Collection and editorial operations", "definition": "Queries, languages, channels, sampling or ranking rules, referrals, search dates, and updates. Separate submitted from actively sought material.", "previous_scope": "Collection", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "collection", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "collections[].counting_rules", "label": "Counting unit and duplicate rules", "group": "Collection and editorial operations", "definition": "State whether a count describes cases, deployments, outcomes, sources, evaluations, or beneficiaries and explain matching/overlap.", "previous_scope": "Collection", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "collection", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "collections[].coverage_limits", "label": "Coverage limits", "group": "Collection and editorial operations", "definition": "Explain selective publicity, language/geography gaps, unavailable private data, and source bias beside aggregate comparisons.", "previous_scope": "Collection", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "collection", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "collections[].capture_cadence", "label": "Collection and review cadence", "group": "Collection and editorial operations", "definition": "Distinguish source collection frequency from review backlog and record freshness.", "previous_scope": "Collection", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "collection", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." }, { "key": "collections[].comparison_denominators", "label": "Population and exposure context", "group": "Collection and editorial operations", "definition": "Store matched denominators and their collection rules where available. A benefits collection alone cannot establish a success rate.", "previous_scope": "Collection", "current_mapping": "new", "level": "collection", "visibility": "public", "requirement": "mandatory_to_address", "resolution_rule": "Provide a supported value, curatorial assignment, or explicit reasoned absence. Unreviewed fields remain incomplete." } ] }